You know the rules. one by subtracting 2, heal another by adding 1. Make it obvious who you're voting for. You can't vote again until 24 hours after your last votes.
The Twin Dilemma: 10
Attack of the Cybermen: 10
Vengeance on Varos: 10
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 10
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 10
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 10
The Twin Dilemma: 10
Attack of the Cybermen: 10
Vengeance on Varos: 10
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 11 (+1)
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 10
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 8 (-2)
The Twin Dilemma: 10
Attack of the Cybermen: 10
Vengeance on Varos: 10
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 11
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 11(+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 6 (-2)
The Twin Dilemma: 8 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 10
Vengeance on Varos: 10
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 12 (+1)
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Twin Dilemma: 6 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 10
Vengeance on Varos: 11(+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 12
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Twin Dilemma: 6
Attack of the Cybermen: 11 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 12
Timelash: 10
Revelation of the Daleks: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 8 (-2)
The Ultimate Foe: 6
This particular set would be much easier if you could take away 2 from 10 of them and add 1 to a single one. Even then I would be hard pressed to know which one to add the single point to.
The Twin Dilemma: 6
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 13 (+1)
Timelash: 8 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 8
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Twin Dilemma: 6
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 14 (+1)
Timelash: 8
Revelation of the Daleks: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 6 (-2)
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Twin Dilemma: 4 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 14
Timelash: 8
Revelation of the Daleks: 12(+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 6
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Twin Dilemma: 2 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 14
Timelash: 9 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 12
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 6
The Ultimate Foe: 6
And yes, for all its faults Timelash is still better than (IMO) 5 other stories here. But I digress...
Merlin
We have our first Casualty!
The Twin Dilemma: 0 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 10
The Two Doctors: 14
Timelash: 9
Revelation of the Daleks: 13(+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 6
The Ultimate Foe: 6
The Two Doctors: 14
Revelation of the Daleks: 13
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Timelash: 9
The Ultimate Foe: 6
Terror of the Vervoids: 4 (-2)
The Twin Dilemma: 0
The Two Doctors: 15 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 13
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Timelash: 7 (-2)
The Ultimate Foe: 6
Terror of the Vervoids: 4
The Twin Dilemma: 0
Back in screening order...
Attack of the Cybermen: 11
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 7
Revelation of the Daleks: 14 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 4
The Ultimate Foe: 4 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 12 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 7
Revelation of the Daleks: 14
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 2 (-2)
The Ultimate Foe: 4
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 5 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 15 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
Terror of the Vervoids: 2
The Ultimate Foe: 4
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 6 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 15
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 4
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 12 (+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 6
Revelation of the Daleks: 15
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 2(-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 13 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 13 (-2)
Timelash: 6
Revelation of the Daleks: 15
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 10
The Ultimate Foe: 2
Interesting that we've had almost 20 plays at this and no one has touched Mysterious Planet or Mindwarp one way or the other. Is it because they just don't happen to be anyone's favourite or most hated from the era, or could it be because they're maybe two of the most forgettable Doctor Who stories ever...? Hmmmm?
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 14 (+1)
Timelash: 6
Revelation of the Daleks: 15
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 8 (-2)
The Ultimate Foe: 2
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 11
The Two Doctors: 14
Timelash: 6
Revelation of the Daleks: 16 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 8
The Ultimate Foe: 0 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 9 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 14
Timelash: 7 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 16
The Mysterious Planet: 10
Mindwarp: 8
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 9
The Two Doctors: 15 (+1)
Timelash: 7
Revelation of the Daleks: 16
The Mysterious Planet: 8 (-2)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 9
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 7
Revelation of the Daleks: 17(+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 6 (-2)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 9
The Two Doctors: 16 (+1)
Timelash: 5 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 17
The Mysterious Planet: 6
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 9
The Two Doctors: 14 (-2)
Timelash: 5
Revelation of the Daleks: 18 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 6
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 7 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 15 (+1)
Timelash: 5
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 6
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 8 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 5
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 4 (-2)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
I just want to comment that I am surprised that Timelash is faring better than most of the Trial of a Time Lord episodes. But mind you, I don't think that Colin Baker's episodes are half as bad as people usually rave about
. So:
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 8
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 3 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 5 (+1)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Sorry, forgot to color code.
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 8
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 3 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 5 (+1)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 12
The Mark of the Rani: 6 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 4 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 5
Mindwarp: 8
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 13(+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 15
Timelash: 2(-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 5
Mindwarp: 8
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 16 (+1)
Timelash: 2
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 3 (-2)
Mindwarp: 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18
The Mysterious Planet: 3
Mindwarp: 8
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 19 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 3
Mindwarp: 6 (-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 14 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 15 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19
The Mysterious Planet: 3
Mindwarp: 6
Attack of the Cybermen: 14
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 16 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19
The Mysterious Planet: 3
Mindwarp: 4 (-2)
Again, due to my liking of Trial of a Time Lord:
Attack of the Cybermen: 12 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 6
The Two Doctors: 16
Revelation of the Daleks: 19
The Mysterious Planet: 4 (+1)
Mindwarp: 4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 4 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19
The Mysterious Planet: 4
Mindwarp: 4
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 4
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 20 (+1)
The Mysterious Planet: 4
Mindwarp: 2(-2)
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Mark of the Rani: 4
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
The Mysterious Planet: 2 (-2)
Mindwarp: 2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 14 (+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 4
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
The Mysterious Planet: 2
Mindwarp: 0 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 12
Vengeance on Varos: 14
The Mark of the Rani: 5 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet: 0 (-2)
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 14
The Mark of the Rani: 5
The Two Doctors: 16 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 14
The Mark of the Rani: 3 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
Attack of the Cybermen: 13
Vengeance on Varos: 15(+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 1 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
Attack of the Cybermen: 11 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 15
The Mark of the Rani: 1
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 9 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 15
The Mark of the Rani: 1
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 21 (+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
I think we're at the point of separation now between the great Colin Baker stories and those that leave something to be desired!
I love all 5 that remain.
Attack of the Cybermen: 7 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 15
The Mark of the Rani: 2 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Sorry Lucas...
Attack of the Cybermen: 7
Vengeance on Varos: 16(+1)
The Mark of the Rani: 0(-2)
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 7
Vengeance on Varos: 14 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 19 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
Attack of the Cybermen: 8 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 14
The Two Doctors: 17 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
Attack of the Cybermen: 8
Vengeance on Varos: 12 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
Attack of the Cybermen: 8
Vengeance on Varos: 13 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 16 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
Attack of the Cybermen: 6 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 4 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 13
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 22(+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Come on peps, how hard is it for you to leave the Hard Return code alone?
Attack of the Cybermen: 5 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 11 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 22
Attack of the Cybermen: 3 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 22
Attack of the Cybermen: 1 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Two Doctors: 19 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 22
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Attack of the Cybermen: 1
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Two Doctors: 17 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 23 (+1)
Attack of the Cybermen: 0 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Two Doctors: 17
Revelation of the Daleks: 24 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 11
The Two Doctors: 15(-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 25 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 9 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 16 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 25
Vengeance on Varos: 9
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 23 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 7 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 23
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Vengeance on Varos: 5 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 18
Revelation of the Daleks: 24(+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Revelation of the Daleks: 22(-2)
The Two Doctors: 19
Vengeance on Varos: 5 (+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Erm, can we stop messing up the order plz?
Vengeance on Varos: 3 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 20 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 22
Vengeance on Varos: 3
The Two Doctors: 21 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 3
The Two Doctors: 19 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 3
The Two Doctors: 17 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 22 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 3
The Two Doctors: 18 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Vengeance on Varos: 1 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 19 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20
Vengeance on Varos: 2 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 19
Revelation of the Daleks: 18 (-2)
Vengeance on Varos: 2
The Two Doctors: 17 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 2
The Two Doctors: 15 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 20 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 2
The Two Doctors: 13 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 21 (+1)
Vengeance on Varos: 2
The Two Doctors: 14 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19 (-2)
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 15 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 19
The Two Doctors: 16 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 17 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos: 0 (-2)
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 17 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 15 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos: 0 (-2)
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 15 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 16 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 13 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 17 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 11 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 18 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 12 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 16 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 13 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 14 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 11 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 15 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 9 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 16 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 7 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 17 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 8 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 15 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 9 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 13 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 10 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 11 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 8 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 12 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 6 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 13 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 7 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 11 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 8 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 9 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 6 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 10 (+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
The Two Doctors: 7 (+1)
Revelation of the Daleks: 8 (-2)
The Two Doctors: 5(-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 9 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 3 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 10 (+1)
The Two Doctors: 4 (+1)Revelation of the Daleks: 8 (-2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
\ The Two Doctors: 2 (-2)
Revelation of the Daleks: 9 (+1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
Please lemme put this sad poll out of its misery . . .
1st: Revelation of the Daleks
2nd: The Two Doctors
3rd: Vengeance on Varos
4th: Attack of the Cybermen
5th: The Mark of the Rani
6th: Mysterious Planet
7th: Mindwarp
8th: Timelash
9th: The Ultimate Foe
10th: Terror of the Vervoids
11th: The Twin Dilemma
I think the results are about spot on.
I'm a little surprised by this spread myself. There's no way "Twin Dilemma" is worse than the worst parts of the Trial of a Time Lord, like "The Ultimate Foe". I tend to rate "Mark of the Rani" as the best of the lot, if only cause it feels like a traditional 70s piece of Who. To me, "The Two Doctors" is way lower on the list; a switch of "Rani" and "Two" would probably make some sense to me. "Revelation", just like McCoy's "Remembrance" is another of those "too-high-fliers". "Varos" and "Mysterious" deserve higher regard for being at least original.
Then again, as soon as I start to care about the ranking of this list, I realize just how awful all the stories really are.
Again, like the McCoy era it's mainly about which serials are 'less bad' than serials I particularly like, although Revelation of the Daleks is the easily my pick of the bunch even with the odious presence of Alexei Sayle (someone I've never even slightly liked either in Revelation, as a stand up, or in the The Young Ones).
I must admit I'm surprised at how highly The Two Doctors is rated.
I think that it largely wastes Patrick Troughton's talent, has weak villains with worse Sontaran costumes than the previous stories, a preposterous setting (clearly picked as a nice place for cast and crew to have a trip), and is way too long.
It's easily the weakest of the multi-doctor serials for me so I'll now be expecting very strong showings for the Three and Five Doctors when we get on to those lists.
Having said all that it's still one of my top 4 stories in the Colin Baker era.
As for the rest I like Venegenace on Varos, parts of Mark of the Rani and can do without the remainder.
The Gallifreyan Embassy - Forum
http://gallifreyanembassy.org/portal/forum/viewtopic.php?showtopic=28300