Subject: Ratings for dw9

Posted on: January 17 2009 @ 01:28 PM
By: Chase

Content:

Rose---8/10---great reintroduction

End of the World---7/10

Unquiet Dead---8/10

Aliens of London—5/10—and that for just the character driven stuff

World War Three---6/10—for all the character driven stuff

Dalek—9/10

The Long Game—1/10—the original idea that Adam stole the info to save his father would have been better

The Empty Child—10/10

The Doctor Dances 10/10

Boom Town—9/10

Bad Wolf—7/10

Parting of the Ways—9/10



Replies:

Ratings for dw9

Posted on: February 25 2009 @ 07:56 PM
By: Aurelius76

Content:

Rose---9/10---actually the story isn't that great; primarily a "9" for it's long awaited return
End of the World---8/10--liked the idea and the fact it wasn't on Earth
Unquiet Dead---7/10
Aliens of London—4/10—first two-parter, but don't really like the aliens
World War Three---4/10
Dalek—6/10--good to see the Daleks again, but a tad bit too emotional for my tastes
The Long Game—7/10—-had a classic Who feel to it Father's Day--8/10--a great story
The Empty Child—9/10--first appearance of Capt. Jack
The Doctor Dances 8/10--not a huge fan of these as everyone else seems to be
Boom Town—5/10--good character development, so-so story
Bad Wolf—6/10--thought game show idea was silly
Parting of the Ways—9/10


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: February 26 2009 @ 03:06 AM
By: Doctor Whoovie

Content:

What about Father's Day Guys?


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: February 26 2009 @ 11:03 AM
By: T Baker(notTom)

Content:

[QUOTE BY= Doctor Whoovie] What about Father's Day Guys?

[/QUOTE]

Aurelius76 has it included - it's just on the same line as "The Long Game".


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: March 08 2009 @ 07:56 PM
By: Chase

Content:

Father's Day 10/10~


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: March 08 2009 @ 10:01 PM
By: merlin_mccarley

Content:


Scream of the Shalka -9/10 (would have been a 10 if they just would have carried on and made more)


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: March 08 2009 @ 11:00 PM
By: Doctor Whoovie

Content:

I think I am a harder marker

Rose--- 6/10 - Okay, Wheelie bin attack is a bit like Dr Emu
End of the World---7/10 - lots of aliens & a good villian
Unquiet Dead---9/10 - best of the series
Aliens of London—5/10 - too much farting
World War Three---4/10
Dalek—--9/10 - excellent episode
The Long Game—--6/10 - okay - probably some extra marks because of Simon Pegg
Father's Day--8/10 - good story , but I still don't get (fear Eek! ) the Reapers?
The Empty Child—8/10 - good spooky episode, let down by stupid barrage balloon scene
The Doctor Dances 7/10 - poor wrap-up to interesting story
Boom Town—4/10 - well who would have thought the Slytheen could get worse
Bad Wolf—7/10 - most of the marks are for the last ten minutes
Parting of the Ways—6/10 - all of the marks are for the first 10 minutes which is classic. What a rubbish ending to the story (not counting regeneration scene in this).


Ratings for dw9

Posted on: March 22 2009 @ 03:15 PM
By: Chase

Content:

I don't know if I put Scream of Shakla down but for me it would a whooping 0/10 for:

the DOctor whooping on the monster, "Take me home big boy" or something like that

The Mastr android companoin? WTF?

The poor cookie cutter companion: we had a black comp in the comics and here Allisn seems so...anemic...

the Plot: UNIT or the army? What again?

Worm monsters: What again?

Paul Cornell: wasn't he the one who blasted Nick Briggs for writing the first DW audio and told him he wasn't the one who was going to bring back DW in any format and it would be he who did it? Sorry Paul it didn't go that way


The Gallifreyan Embassy - Forum
http://gallifreyanembassy.org/portal/forum/viewtopic.php?showtopic=29335