Become a Podshock Supporting Subscriber
Now more than ever, we need your support! Become a Supporting Subscriber today.

Hurt/Heal: Series 31


Idiom's picture

Idiom - Posted on 27 July 2010

Should be a short one this.  Same rules as always - vote only once every 24 hoursTake 2 points from the episode you want to vote out, Add 1 point to the episode you want to keep.

Here are the candidates:

The Eleventh Hour   10          The Beast Below   10        Victory of the Daleks   10

The Time of Angels   10         Flesh and Stone   10          The Vampires of Venice   10

Amy’s Choice   10                   The Hungry Earth   10      Cold blood   10

Vincent and the Doctor   10  The Lodger   10      The Pandorica opens   10

The Big Bang   10

 

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23      The Time of Angels  6           
The Pandorica opens   2   
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Doctor Whoovie's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23      The Time of Angels  4           
The Pandorica opens   3   
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

namariee's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23      The Time of Angels  2           
The Pandorica opens   4   
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

 

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23      The Time of Angels  3           
The Pandorica opens   2   
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Doctor Whoovie's picture

Had to vote a few hours early, as I will be on an airplane for the rest of the day.

Looks like the regulars have voted already, so I don't think I'm taking unfair advantage

 

The Eleventh Hour 23      The Time of Angels  1           
The Pandorica opens   3   
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Idiom's picture

forget that - my vote was right but Whoovie posted his vote as a reply to mine which confused me

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23              
The Pandorica opens   3   
The Big Bang   21   

  _______________________________________________

4) The Time of Angels 0

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24              
The Pandorica opens   1   
The Big Bang   21   

  _______________________________________________

4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

namariee's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24               
The Big Bang   22   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 22               
The Big Bang   23   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23               
The Big Bang   21   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

namariee's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24               
The Big Bang   19   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Doctor Whoovie's picture

The Eleventh Hour 22              
The Big Bang   20   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23              
The Big Bang   18   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24              
The Big Bang   16   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 25              
The Big Bang   14   

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Doctor Whoovie's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23              
The Big Bang   15  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24              
The Big Bang   13  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

namariee's picture

The Eleventh Hour 22              
The Big Bang   14  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 23              
The Big Bang   12  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 24              
The Big Bang   10  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

Yes, back watching the Pertwee's.....

The Eleventh Hour 25              
The Big Bang   8  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

namariee's picture

The Eleventh Hour 26              
The Big Bang   6  

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 27             
The Big Bang   4 

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Doctor Whoovie's picture

I find it a little worrying that a story where Steven Moffat blatantly plagarized himself is considered the best episode of the season. 

The Eleventh Hour 25             
The Big Bang   5 

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Idiom's picture

Best season opener since Rose in my opinion. I tend to look at it as the development of themes rather than plagarism.

Mr. Magister's picture

The Eleventh Hour 26             
The Big Bang   3 

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister

Idiom's picture

The Eleventh Hour 27      
The Big Bang   1

  _______________________________________________

3) The Pandorica Opens  4) The Time of Angels

5) Vincent and the Doctor  6) Flesh and Stone 7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    9) The Lodger  10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

namariee's picture

1) The Eleventh Hour
2) The Big Bang
3) The Pandorica Opens
4) The Time of Angels
5) Vincent and the Doctor
6) Flesh and Stone 
7) The Hungry Earth   
8) Cold blood    
9) The Lodger  
10) Amy's Choice  
11) The Vampires of Venice    
 
12) The Beast Below 
13) Victory of the Daleks

Mr. Magister's picture

Ok - this turned out much as I would expect.  Look at the top 6.  To me, they are all interchangeable.  They were all 'Good' episodes.  Good meaning 7's or 8's on a scale of 1-10 or four Tardis groans.  That's pretty good - but there were no WOW episodes - they came close mind you, but there's just SOMETHING that's missing.  I've seen other posts and tweets saying likewise...but what is it???  It's not Matt Smith - he's great, no argument.  But what is it????  Could it be those precious 4-5 minutes that are being trimmed to fit the current format?  Could be!!!  Give us just a few seconds...300 of them to further flesh out characters or a means for the Doctor to escape a jamb w/out falling on this crutch sonic screwdriver.  (It ruined Cold Blood for me when he kept disarming the Silurians with it...enough is enough....where's a Teriliptil when you need him!)

Regarding the bottom half - again, there's not a 'Fear Her' in the bunch....but I'd only describe anything below the top 6 simply as 'Ok' - no great shakes, I was disappointed w/ the Silurian episodes on the whole...could have been better, but nothing terrible.  My only comment on this list would be that I would have had Vampires of Venice a little higher.  I thought it was good use of Rory and the 'Fish People' were fantastically realized.  In fact, I've never heard any positive things about the special effects for that episide at all - why is that?   The scenes where the Queen's Perception Filter was failing as she was walking around, or down the steps I thought were top notch for 2010 Who.  Oh well.

Mr. Magister

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

New Doctor Who Podshock schwag

Podcast Feeds

Subscribe to
the Doctor Who podcast
Doctor Who: Podshock


iTunes users click here
Podcast
Gallifreyan Embassy - Doctor Who: Podshock - Doctor Who: Podshock


Direct podcast feeds:


Doctor Who: Podshock
Podcast


MP3 Format Podcast:
Doctor Who: Podshock MP3
Podcast


  More feeds and info

  Supporting Subscribers

BEST PODCAST

Doctor Who: Podshock Awarded BEST PODCAST
Doctor Who: PODSHOCK

DW Podshock App

iPhone, iPad, iPod touch podcast companion app

Doctor Who: Podshock Podcast Companion App

Doctor Who: Podshock Companion App

Syndicate (RSS Feed)

Syndicate content

Poll

How do you rate Doctor Who: The Mark of the Rani? (5=Fantastic)
5 TARDIS Groans
0%
4 TARDIS Groans
100%
3 TARDIS Groans
0%
2 TARDIS Groans
0%
1 TARDIS Groan
0%
0 TARDIS Groans
0%
Total votes: 1

Amazon US Store


Doctor Who Episodes

Amazon UK Store

Latest image

DW Podshock 301 Cover

BBC Shop (UK & Europe)

Monthly archive