The Mark of the Rani

Chase - Posted on 26 July 2009


Well I've always enjoyed this story and this watching just reinforced that. Yeah, there are problems but I've always tended to overlook them. Part one, as almost all Colin stories aspire to, is inspiring and very, very good. THIS is the way to introduce a new villain and THIS is the way to treat the Rani. Every other appearance by her tends to reduce her to the I want to rule the world villainess one dimensional charcter. Here, she's very much a 3d character IMO. She doesn't want to rule the world, or change time or do anything that fools like Ming the Merciless and the Master and Dr Evil want to do: she has reasons and good ones.  She is amoral but not totally evil and not for evil's sake. I still hate her for what she does to Luke and the others but not as much as I hate the Master for killing the dog and the dog's owner. I hate when they have animals die in media but whatever...

The location work is just amazing and looks like...well, not like DW. It's just so back then, back there and looks great. On the negative side, I can't really understand the miners alot of the time and need subtitles. In fact, some slang and dialects of British sound more foreign to me than French, Japanese, and Chinese! Scottish, also sounds sometimes like an alien language but that's my problem.

Peri's dress: she should have nipped back into the TARDIS and changed it pronto,however, it does make her fit into the past more easily than the things she wore in ATTACK and VAROS. She and the Doc do disagree but not terribly or am I just getting used to their horrid fights? And insults? I don't care: they both work here and in this I found myself routing for them one hundred percent, which I can't always say I did with Peri. And as for the Doc in MINDWARP...more on that later or later on that more...or whatever...

I like all the actors here, the sets are great, some of them borrowed from TENKO. Why the Master was dressed as a scarecrow I don't know and why the birds didn't sing I don' t know....perhaps they smelled the foul thing known as the Master. Frankly, I love the whole Master/Rani/Doctor banter between all of them, two of them, and their encounters with poor Peri ("who is this brat?" "I have a score to settle with Miss Brown" "A hyperactive Peri is too ghastly to think about"). There are some great lines here from all involved especially Peri, the Rani, The Master, and the Doctor ("Where is that idiot?" "I assume your talking about the Master..." "I begin to understand why the Master finds you such a threat") and so on. While it's clear the Doctor and the Rani know each other, it's not THAT well. I mean they certianly have not crossed swords as much as the Doctor and the Master if at all.     

ON ANOTHER NOTE : since I want to write a fan fiction about it, does anyone know the nature of the aliens or the world Miasimia Goria. The Master speaks of it intrigingly as the aliens there have useful ...uses and they must have some special talents he alludes to but never reveals. Does any other spinoff explain these aliens or that world? I looked and looked but found nothing. It's another annoying particular of DW to mention something and then never expand on it and even more annoying that some writer somewhere obsure will touch on it but never let anyone know as in RACE AGAINST TIME, the Rani Choose Your Own Adventure. If anywhere I imagine it would be there but I can't find that.

Anyway HERE the Rani is markedly different from the Penquin...I mean the Master. The Master is insane as the Rani claims. Why she couldn't stop him earlier just proves how powerful he really is, blackmailing her. Kate O'Mara carries herself well in this and proves apt to play such a Time Lord/Lady. She's no lady though. The slugs are digusting and remind me of STAR TREK 2. The cliffhanger is a bit awkward and I like that the Doctor doesn't show the Master any worry...a tip of the hat to Colin for not showing any worry but bluffing that he thnks it is another illusion  on the Rani's screen (he doesn't, he's bluffing so that the Master can't gloat over his worry and then kill him after that satisfication). The Doc knows the Master won't kill him until he's humiliated and the Doc remains calm. That bit is always missed somehow when one talks about this story. Of course, he should be more worried about Peri...but he does show it some how ("Peri, keep back" "And get out...")

A good story and Luke Ward is another in a long line of hunks this season, many of them blond...  


Again, the curse of part two for Colin. What annoyed and still annoys me about this story is the fact that in the second part it hardly feels like  a  story at all or maybe it does but it's BATMAN, the classic series story. The Doctor should have killed the Master and the Rani outright, then I but not 1000 other fans would have had more respect for him. He also seemed to just miss saving Luke Ward by fact, the way it looks, he COULD have warned Luke while watching with the Rani and the Master from the hill above.

I'm also not sure but uhm, how did the Doc know the Master had a remedy for the sleeplessness? In fact, unless I"m not paying attention, how did the Master come by it? Did we know about this remedy?

ABOUT TIME 6 has a whole load more reasons why it seems that no one cared about the logic of the stories or how it all fit into the history of DW...the Master and the Rani shuld have known the Doc must have seen tv screens that could allow illusions to be given by the the Doc and the Time Lords have done it before...

Still, the Rani's TARDIS is a nice set and kinda pretty in a Goth kind of way. The Master and the Rani do pay for their crimes. Was she planning on using the T Rex's against the Doctor? Why does it seem as if the Master worries that the cave in might destroy the Rani, himself and the TARDIS they are in? Why did the Master think the TARDIS was finished by throwing into a mine? Why did the Master not just hypnotize Luke rather than use the maggots? Maybe he didn't feel that confident in his use of it? Why didn't anyone else sense Luke was acting strangely...oh wait, the Doc did but let Luke go off what we have in another kind of mess to be honest. This one's sort of fun to watch but it wears after a few viewings. There's the hint it could have been better.


I don't know.  I have always kind of liked this story.  As the Colin Baker stories were coming out in DVD, the one I kept waiting for was this one.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

New Doctor Who Podshock schwag

Podcast Feeds

Subscribe to
the Doctor Who podcast
Doctor Who: Podshock

iTunes users click here
Gallifreyan Embassy - Doctor Who: Podshock - Doctor Who: Podshock

Direct podcast feeds:

Doctor Who: Podshock

MP3 Format Podcast:
Doctor Who: Podshock MP3

  More feeds and info

  Supporting Subscribers

Syndicate (RSS Feed)

Syndicate content


How do you rate Doctor Who: Thin Ice? (5=Fantastic)
5 TARDIS Groans
4 TARDIS Groans
3 TARDIS Groans
2 TARDIS Groans
1 TARDIS Groan
0 TARDIS Groans
Total votes: 1

Amazon US Store

Amazon UK Store

Latest image

DW Podshock 341 Cover