First Memories and a Reminder

barnabeee's picture

barnabeee - Posted on 04 August 2009

While listening to TARDIS Tara’s semi-live Comic-Con reports Podshock Episode 157, and reading and hearing various other reports on the Doctor Who panel, one comment really stood out in my mind. That was Julie Gardner’s comment on what made her fall in love with Doctor Who. She reported that the first story that Russell showed her when they started work on the series was the Season 17 story “City of Death”, and from that moment she said she has been a confirmed fan.

Now Season 17 frequently gets a bad rap from the fan community, but it’s my favourite season of all them – including the Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant years! And it was my first.  As a six year old, my first, very vivid memory of Doctor Who is the first cliffhanger of City of Death as the sinister count reveals his true persona – wobbly mask and all. I was duly terrified and had to watch next week – when I got to experience the thrills of a chicken that turned into a skeleton, and back into an egg, and more of the well dressed one-eyed green man. How thrilling! I was hooked for life! Even more so when I got to see the great big pit creature, the menacing Mandrels, and the sparkly bulls wearing loincloths over the following weeks. I loved them all – and didn’t care that the effects might have looked cheap, or that it was being played for laughs – my imagination was captured by this weird man in a scarf, his lady friend and tin dog, and all these alien-looking creatures and planets. Autumn 1979 was the year that this Doctor Who fan was born – in a world of just 3 channels, and every Saturday after Grandstand I was by the television, waiting.

The following year when the show (finally) came back I was absolutely pertrified when that nice safe man with the scarf got spikes all over his face and started killing people. Yes – its another not-quite-so-well regarded story. But to this 7 year old, it was great. (I should probably also admit at this point that my favourite story from the “Five Faces of Doctor Who” repeat season that showed up the following year was “The Krotons” by a country mile!)

So why tell you all this? Well, other than to completely devalue my standing as knowing what is and is not “good” Doctor Who from the typical fan perspective – but who wants to be typical? Not me! – it’s to remind us all that Doctor Who is first and foremost a kids show, which sometimes we forget when complaining about aliens that make slightly rude noises, or villains not taking themselves completely seriously, or scientists with silly accents. Russell T Davies, Julie Gardner, Phil Collinson and the rest of the Cardiff team for the last 5 years never forgot that, and I hope Steven Moffat and his team don’t either! And most of all, we shouldn’t forget it – it’s so much more fun to just go along for the ride! I’m can’t wait for the next one, but in the meantime, I’ve got Nightmare of Eden, The Krotons, and Planet of the Dead, and many, many more, to watch a few more times!

Keefe O's picture

I really enjoyed this post. Laughing

For me, Doctor Who is all about having a completely open imagination, enjoying the ride, and being open to change (which yes, can be hard at times).  My favorite will always be Revenge of the Cybermen.   




tarashnat's picture

My first experience with Doctor Who was in the late seventies when the first four seasons of Tom Baker were being aired on Saturdays on WOR in New York City. I remember the shoddy CSO on the Giant Robot in Robot, but the memory that most sticks in my memory is the creepy Davros ordering his two Daleks to kill the scientists from Genesis of the Daleks. For a long time, this was the limit of my exposure to Doctor Who until sometime in the mid eighties when I chanced on the last ten minutes of episode 4 of The Caves of Androzani while surfing the UHF band one summer afternoon. In that four year run, though, only one of the Doctor's enemies appeared more than once, and that was the Sontarans. I think that many people still like this era because there was so little repetition. We had the Doctor finally leaving his UNIT friends behind and going off into the universe. Though at the time, I was totally unaware of the whole Pertwee/exile era. Actually, the Third Doctor era was the last of the classic series that I was exposed to.

I also like Nightmare of Eden and The Horns of Nimon, but for their ideas and stories, not so much the execution. I'm not sure if the labor action that derailed Shada had any effect on those two serials, but they do suffer a bit on the production side. 

Have we done the crash of the Byzantium yet?

DWNY a New York City based Doctor Who meet up group.

New Doctor Who Podshock schwag

Podcast Feeds

Subscribe to
the Doctor Who podcast
Doctor Who: Podshock

iTunes users click here
Gallifreyan Embassy - Doctor Who: Podshock - Doctor Who: Podshock

Direct podcast feeds:

Doctor Who: Podshock

MP3 Format Podcast:
Doctor Who: Podshock MP3

  More feeds and info

  Supporting Subscribers

Syndicate (RSS Feed)

Syndicate content


How do you rate Doctor Who: Thin Ice? (5=Fantastic)
5 TARDIS Groans
4 TARDIS Groans
3 TARDIS Groans
2 TARDIS Groans
1 TARDIS Groan
0 TARDIS Groans
Total votes: 1

Amazon US Store

Amazon UK Store

Latest image

DW Podshock 341 Cover